Calibration Report: research

Mission: research
Date: 2026-04-27
Overlay: .kittify/doctrine/overlays/calibration-research.yaml
Status: No edge changes required — all steps pass §4.5.1

Summary

All 6 steps pass the §4.5.1 inequality. The shipped src/doctrine/graph.yaml already provides the required context for every step. Transitive extras surfaced via DIRECTIVE_003 → requires → tactic:adr-drafting-workflow and DIRECTIVE_037 → suggests → tactic:acceptance-test-first / atdd-adversarial-acceptance / usage-examples-sync are classified as known_irrelevant.

Step-by-Step Findings

Step: scoping

Column	Value
Step id	scoping
Action id	`action:research/scoping`
Profile id	`agent_profile:researcher-robbie`
Resolved DRG artifact URNs	`directive:DIRECTIVE_003`, `directive:DIRECTIVE_010`, `tactic:adr-drafting-workflow`†, `tactic:premortem-risk-identification`, `tactic:requirements-validation-workflow`
Scope edges involved	`directive:DIRECTIVE_003`, `directive:DIRECTIVE_010`, `tactic:premortem-risk-identification`, `tactic:requirements-validation-workflow`
Missing context	none
Irrelevant / too-broad context	none
Recommended DRG edge changes	none
Before/after evidence	Before: 5 URNs. After: unchanged.

Step: methodology

Column	Value
Step id	methodology
Action id	`action:research/methodology`
Profile id	`agent_profile:researcher-robbie`
Resolved DRG artifact URNs	`directive:DIRECTIVE_003`, `directive:DIRECTIVE_010`, `tactic:adr-drafting-workflow`, `tactic:premortem-risk-identification`†, `tactic:requirements-validation-workflow`
Scope edges involved	`directive:DIRECTIVE_003`, `directive:DIRECTIVE_010`, `tactic:adr-drafting-workflow`, `tactic:requirements-validation-workflow`
Missing context	none
Irrelevant / too-broad context	none
Recommended DRG edge changes	none
Before/after evidence	Before: 5 URNs. After: unchanged.

Step: gathering

Column	Value
Step id	gathering
Action id	`action:research/gathering`
Profile id	`agent_profile:researcher-robbie`
Resolved DRG artifact URNs	`directive:DIRECTIVE_003`, `directive:DIRECTIVE_037`, `tactic:acceptance-test-first`†, `tactic:adr-drafting-workflow`†, `tactic:atdd-adversarial-acceptance`†, `tactic:premortem-risk-identification`†, `tactic:requirements-validation-workflow`, `tactic:usage-examples-sync`†
Scope edges involved	`directive:DIRECTIVE_003`, `directive:DIRECTIVE_037`, `tactic:requirements-validation-workflow`
Missing context	none
Irrelevant / too-broad context	none (†transitive from `DIRECTIVE_037 → suggests` chain)
Recommended DRG edge changes	none
Before/after evidence	Before: 8 URNs. After: unchanged.

Step: synthesis

Column	Value
Step id	synthesis
Action id	`action:research/synthesis`
Profile id	`agent_profile:researcher-robbie`
Resolved DRG artifact URNs	`directive:DIRECTIVE_003`, `directive:DIRECTIVE_010`, `tactic:adr-drafting-workflow`†, `tactic:premortem-risk-identification`, `tactic:requirements-validation-workflow`
Scope edges involved	`directive:DIRECTIVE_003`, `directive:DIRECTIVE_010`, `tactic:premortem-risk-identification`, `tactic:requirements-validation-workflow`
Missing context	none
Irrelevant / too-broad context	none
Recommended DRG edge changes	none
Before/after evidence	Before: 5 URNs. After: unchanged.

Step: output

Column	Value
Step id	output
Action id	`action:research/output`
Profile id	`agent_profile:researcher-robbie`
Resolved DRG artifact URNs	`directive:DIRECTIVE_010`, `directive:DIRECTIVE_037`, `tactic:acceptance-test-first`†, `tactic:atdd-adversarial-acceptance`†, `tactic:requirements-validation-workflow`, `tactic:usage-examples-sync`†
Scope edges involved	`directive:DIRECTIVE_010`, `directive:DIRECTIVE_037`, `tactic:requirements-validation-workflow`
Missing context	none
Irrelevant / too-broad context	none
Recommended DRG edge changes	none
Before/after evidence	Before: 6 URNs. After: unchanged.

Step: retrospect

Column	Value
Step id	retrospect
Action id	`action:research/retrospect`
Profile id	`agent_profile:retrospective-facilitator`
Resolved DRG artifact URNs	`agent_profile:retrospective-facilitator`, `directive:DIRECTIVE_003/010/018`, `styleguide:kitty-glossary-writing`, `tactic:adr-drafting-workflow`, `tactic:autonomous-operation-protocol`, `tactic:glossary-curation-interview`, `tactic:premortem-risk-identification`, `tactic:requirements-validation-workflow`, `tactic:stopping-conditions`
Scope edges involved	Full retrospect scope (all the above are direct `scope` edges added by WP01)
Missing context	none
Irrelevant / too-broad context	none
Recommended DRG edge changes	none
Before/after evidence	Before: 11 URNs. After: unchanged.