---
type: "ADR"
title: "Record Architecture Decisions"
description: "Adopts lightweight one-decision-per-file ADRs as the durable home for architectural rationale, so settled choices stop being relitigated in chat history."
status: "stable"
generated:
  by: "process:dockitty-export"
  at: "2026-01-23T00:00:00Z"
---

## Context and Problem Statement

As Spec Kitty grows in complexity, we need a systematic way to document significant architectural decisions. Team members (both human and AI agents) need to understand:
- Why certain approaches were chosen
- What alternatives were considered
- What tradeoffs were accepted
- What consequences resulted from decisions

Without structured decision documentation, we face:
- Loss of architectural context over time
- Repeated debates about settled decisions
- Difficulty onboarding new contributors
- Unclear rationale for existing patterns

## Decision Drivers

- Need to preserve architectural knowledge as project evolves
- Multiple AI agents need clear decision context
- Want to avoid "tribal knowledge" that exists only in conversation history
- Need accountability for architectural choices
- Want to learn from both successful and unsuccessful decisions

## Considered Options

- **Option 1:** No formal decision documentation (status quo)
- **Option 2:** Architecture Decision Records (ADRs)
- **Option 3:** Design documents in wiki
- **Option 4:** Comprehensive architecture specification document

## Decision Outcome

**Chosen option:** "Option 2: Architecture Decision Records (ADRs)", because:
- Lightweight and low-overhead (fits agile development)
- One decision per document (focused and digestible)
- Immutable once accepted (provides historical record)
- Widely adopted standard with excellent tooling
- Works well with version control (git)
- AI agents can easily read and reference ADRs

### Consequences

#### Positive

- Architectural decisions are documented and discoverable
- New team members can understand decision history
- AI agents have clear context for development work
- Prevents revisiting settled decisions repeatedly
- Creates knowledge base of tradeoffs and lessons learned
- Supports code reviews with architectural validation

#### Negative

- Requires discipline to create ADRs consistently
- Additional documentation overhead
- Risk of ADRs becoming stale if not maintained

#### Neutral

- ADRs are stored in `architecture/1.x/adr/` and `architecture/2.x/adr/` directory
- Use sequential numbering (0001, 0002, etc.)
- Follow standardized template format

### Confirmation

We'll know this decision is successful if:
- ADRs are consistently created for significant decisions
- Team references ADRs during code reviews and planning
- New contributors find ADRs helpful for understanding codebase
- Decision rationale is clear 6+ months after decisions are made

## Pros and Cons of the Options

### Option 1: No Formal Decision Documentation

**Pros:**
- No overhead or process burden
- Maximum flexibility

**Cons:**
- Architectural knowledge lost over time
- Decisions must be reverse-engineered from code
- Repeated debates about settled issues
- Difficult onboarding for new contributors

### Option 2: Architecture Decision Records (ADRs)

**Pros:**
- Lightweight and focused (one decision per document)
- Immutable historical record
- Widely adopted industry standard
- Works well with version control
- Easy for AI agents to read and reference
- Template-driven for consistency

**Cons:**
- Requires discipline to maintain
- Documentation overhead for each decision
- Can become stale if not kept in sync

### Option 3: Design Documents in Wiki

**Pros:**
- Easy to update and edit
- Can include diagrams and rich media
- Searchable and cross-linked

**Cons:**
- Separate from code repository
- Encourages editing rather than superseding
- No clear versioning or history
- Can become monolithic and hard to navigate

### Option 4: Comprehensive Architecture Specification

**Pros:**
- Single comprehensive reference
- Covers entire system architecture

**Cons:**
- Becomes outdated quickly
- Too large to read or maintain
- Doesn't capture decision history or alternatives
- Difficult to determine when decisions were made

## More Information

### Template and Guidelines

- See `architecture/adr-template.md` for the standard ADR template
- See `architecture/README.md` for naming conventions and process

### External References

This decision follows the approach documented in:
- Michael Nygard's "Documenting Architecture Decisions" (2011)
- [ADR GitHub Organization](https://adr.github.io/)
- [AWS ADR Best Practices](https://docs.aws.amazon.com/prescriptive-guidance/latest/architectural-decision-records/)
- [Microsoft Azure ADR Guidance](https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/azure/well-architected/architect-role/architecture-decision-record)

### Related Decisions

- All subsequent ADRs follow the format established here
