Architect lens — seams, types, and concrete shapes

Raw squad report, 2026-07-26. Profile-loaded, read-only. Preserved verbatim as the evidence base for creed-and-values-design-hardened.md. Forbidden-legacy-term literals are redacted where quoted, so the docs terminology guard stays green.

I have the full picture. Here is the hardening.

---

Hardening: creed / FoundationalValues / impacts

Profile directives applied: 001, 003, 031, 032, 041, 043, 044 + tactic development-bdd (stated above). All paths relative to /home/stijn/Documents/_code/SDD/fork/spec-kitty/.worktrees/docs-manifesto-tier. Read-only; no git run, no file edited.

---

FINDINGS

[BLOCKER] tests/architectural/test_artifact_selection_completeness.py:55-62 — _doctrine_artifact_kinds() discovers every @property on DoctrineService by introspection, and demands a matching selected_<kind> on DoctrineSelectionConfig (src/charter/schemas.py:82) and required_<kind> on OrgCharterPolicy. DoctrineService has exactly 9 properties today (src/doctrine/service.py:65-150). → Do not expose the value-set repository as a DoctrineService property. Doing so silently converts a 2-file change into a 3-way lockstep across two packages. Expose it via a named accessor (resolve_active_value_set()), not a property.

[BLOCKER] src/charter/sync.py:249-251 — the canonical section-loader pattern treats an absent section as "empty config" with an logger.info. That is the 3-for-3 decay shape the verdict names (Directive.severity: 162 days inert behind green tests). A load_creed_config that copies this fallback ships pre-decayed. → load_creed_config must return a three-state result (absent / partial / complete), and the absent state must be surfaced by run_consistency_check (src/charter/consistency_check.py:1050), not logged at info.

[MAJOR] src/charter/schemas.py:286 — CharterYaml is frozen=True, extra="forbid", but it is only ever constructed (src/charter/compiler.py:573, src/specify_cli/upgrade/migrations/m_unify_charter_activation_finalize.py:223); model_validate against the on-disk document appears only in tests (tests/charter/test_charter_yaml_model.py:86). Every production reader goes through raw ruamel (src/charter/charter_yaml_io.py:90, consumed at src/charter/sync.py:227). → A creed: block on disk would be silently unvalidated: the mirror image of the three silent-drop sites. The validation entry point must be an explicit per-section CreedConfig.model_validate(...) at the sync.py:252 seam.

[MAJOR] src/doctrine/tactics/models.py:74 + src/doctrine/schemas/tactic.schema.yaml:6 — dual gate. Models are extra="forbid"; schemas are additionalProperties: false and are not enforced at load (src/doctrine/base.py:175 calls only model_validate; src/doctrine/tactics/validation.py:17 has no callers) but are enforced by tests/doctrine/test_artifact_compliance.py:21 / test_tactic_compliance.py:68. → Every per-artefact field must land in both places in one commit, ×6 kinds = 12 files minimum.

[MAJOR] tests/doctrine/drg/test_kind_mapping_totality.py:49-52 — _ENUM_CLASSES understands ArtifactKind and NodeKind only. A Relation-keyed table (e.g. "which relations may carry impacts") has no totality guard and will rot on the next Relation addition. → If Part 2 introduces any dict[Relation, ...], it must ship a Relation arm on this scanner in the same commit (DIRECTIVE_043: close the class, don't add to it).

[MAJOR] src/doctrine/tactics/built-in/analysis/ammerse-impact-analysis.tactic.yaml:61-62 and :68 — the composition algebra is already shipped doctrine: base + (0.5 × first_order_sum / 6), and overall = base + (0.5 × first_order) + (0.25 × second_order). → delta == base, and it is the only term that may ever be persisted. Any schema with a field able to hold first_order or overall contradicts an activated tactic (.kittify/config.yaml:53, .kittify/charter/charter.yaml:1436, src/charter/packs/default.yaml:47). This is Q5's invariant, and it is authored, not invented.

[MAJOR] src/doctrine/drg/models.py:299-303 — DRGNode.provenance is excluded from graph.yaml by "the extractor's explicit field-by-field writer". A new DRGEdge.impacts will therefore not round-trip unless that writer is taught the field — a silent-drop of exactly the class the verdict catalogues, in a fourth site nobody has listed.

[MAJOR] src/charter/schemas.py:164 (Directive.severity: str = "warn") and :149 (GovernanceConfig.enforcement: dict[str,str]) are still present. Shipping a creed scoring register beside two known-dead ones voluntarily reproduces 070edbd4f. → Campsite-delete both in the same mission that adds creed, per the verdict's WP01.

[MAJOR] src/charter/consistency_check.py:934-952 — _tension_candidate_pairs builds pair membership by exact relation equality (:947) and set membership (:949). If impacts became the membership criterion (a "tension band"), pair membership becomes a function of a tunable threshold — and the verdict measured that no threshold separates genuine tensions (4–6) from unrelated pairs (2–4), overlapping at 4. → impacts must never gate membership. (Recommendation below.)

[MINOR] src/charter/charter_yaml_io.py:61-66 — _SCALAR_SECTIONS / OWNED_SECTIONS; writing an unlisted section raises UnknownCharterYamlSectionError (:151). "creed" must be added to _SCALAR_SECTIONS, which is the correct one-line extension — it inherits the INV-9 anti-clobber invariant built for exactly this.

[MINOR] .kittify/charter/ already carries five orphaned residue files (directives.yaml, governance.yaml, metadata.yaml, references.yaml, graph.yml) — none has a src writer. A sibling creed.yaml is the known residue-accumulation failure mode in this exact directory.

[MINOR] src/charter/schemas.py:313-334 — _OPTIONAL_EMPTY_OMIT_KEYS + _prune_optional_empties (:337) enforce NFR-005 byte-stability. An absent creed must serialize to nothing, so creed must be CreedConfig | None = None, not a default_factory.

[MINOR] src/doctrine/base.py:308-311 — _merge is {**built_in.model_dump(), **project_data}: whole-field replace. An org pack overriding a tactic's value vector replaces all seven axes; per-axis tuning is impossible. This is the right semantic (a half-authored vector is worse than none) but it must be documented, because operators will expect per-axis merge.

[MINOR] src/doctrine/templates/architecture/ammerse-analysis-template.md:69 vs .../ammerse-impact-analysis.tactic.yaml:41-42 — Environmental has lost "impact on nature and society" → "societal/ethical impact". Authoring 36 delta vectors against a drifted definition bakes the drift into data. DIRECTIVE_044 unification is a prerequisite, not a follow-up.

[NOTE] src/doctrine/drg/migration/extractor.py:133-145 (_KIND_MAP, 11 entries), src/charter/context.py:668-683 (_classify_artifact_urns, four elif, no else), src/doctrine/drg/query.py:230-242 (16 kinds bucketed, 10 read out) — these do not bite the design as specified below, because nothing new becomes a DRG node. See Q6.

---

Q1 — FoundationalValues as a "half-open enum"

Verdict: do not build an enum, and do not build a half-open type. The construct does not need to exist.

Reasoning, in three steps:

1. A closed StrEnum is wrong and the codebase proves why: tests/doctrine/test_artifact_kinds.py:32 pins the exact 12-member set as a hardcoded literal, tests/doctrine/drg/test_kind_mapping_totality.py:183 AST-scans all of src/ for kind-keyed tables and demands totality-or-exemption, and tests/doctrine/drg/test_models.py:58 pins set(RELATION_DESCRIPTIONS) == set(Relation). Every enum in this repo is deliberately consumer-hostile. A consumer-replaceable set inside that machinery means "fork the CLI" — the objection the verdict raised at manifesto-tier-verdict-and-handover.md:168.

2. The three-tier repository layering gives most of what is wanted, but not all of it. BaseDoctrineRepository (src/doctrine/base.py:82) requires only _schema (:114) and _glob (:122) — it does not require an ArtifactKind member, an ArtifactKind plural, a glob entry, or a NodeKind. That is the enabling fact: you can have a built-in→org→project layered doctrine repository with zero enum surface and zero DRG surface. Confirmed by construction: AgentProfileRepository (src/doctrine/agent_profiles/repository.py:219) and MissionTemplateRepository (src/doctrine/missions/repository.py:80) already sit outside BaseDoctrineRepository, and asset has no repository at all. What layering does not give you: _merge at src/doctrine/base.py:308-311 is a whole-field replace keyed on obj.id. enhances/overrides are per-artefact-ID augmentation edges (src/doctrine/drg/models.py:229-247) — they cannot express "add an eighth value to the built-in seven." An org replacing the value set replaces the whole set artefact, atomically. That is the correct semantic (a mixed 7+1 basis with a 7×7 matrix is incoherent) and it is exactly the "open–closed" the design asks for: closed for modification, open for substitution.

3. The openness lives in the artefact, not the type. Concrete shape:

• No enum. ValueKey = str, constrained by Field(pattern=r"^[a-z][a-z0-9_]*$").
• FoundationalValue — frozen Pydantic model {key, name, description}.
• ValueSet — frozen Pydantic model owning an ordered list of FoundationalValue plus the connascence matrix; exposes keys: frozenset[ValueKey] as a computed property. This is the runtime authority against which every per-artefact vector is validated. Validation is against the active ValueSet, never against a module-level literal.
• ValueSetRepository(BaseDoctrineRepository[ValueSet]) — _glob = "*.valueset.yaml", built-in dir src/doctrine/values/built-in/. Free built-in→org→project substitution, zero enum cost, zero DRG cost.
• The openness guard (this is the part that makes it stay open, DIRECTIVE_043): an architectural test asserting that no module under src/ contains a literal collection of the seven AMMERSE keys. Enum drift-guards pin a set closed; this pins it open. Without it, the first consumer of the value set will hardcode ("agile", "minimal", ...) for a lookup table and re-close the set six months later, silently.

---

Q2 — Where creed lives, exactly

A creed: top-level block on charter.yaml. Not a new .kittify/charter/creed.yaml. And the weights split from the value set.

Concern	Home	Why
Value names, descriptions, N×N matrix	src/doctrine/values/built-in/ammerse.valueset.yaml (doctrine tier, org-replaceable)	Reusable library knowledge, project-independent — the thing the verdict said must not be project data in a library, inverted: this half genuinely is library data
Weights ("how important is this to us") + per-value rationale	charter.yaml → creed: block	Project-specific operator declaration. Resolves verdict objection at manifesto-tier-verdict-and-handover.md:203

Why a block, not a sibling file — three citable reasons:

1. src/charter/bundle.py:128-131 — CANONICAL_MANIFEST declares tracked_files=[CHARTER_MD, CHARTER_YAML] and content_hash_files=[CHARTER_YAML]. A sibling file must additionally be threaded into the manifest (:76), the content hash (:141), first_missing_bundle_file (:199), the freshness computer's _BUNDLE_FILES (src/specify_cli/charter_runtime/freshness/computer.py:295-331), and the bundle CLI gate (src/specify_cli/cli/commands/charter_bundle.py:290-313). A block inherits all five for free.
2. .kittify/charter/ already holds five unowned residue files. Adding a sixth is the demonstrated failure mode of that directory.
3. src/charter/charter_yaml_io.py:114 update_charter_yaml_section is the INV-9 anti-clobber chokepoint built precisely because three writers mutate one file. Adding "creed" to _SCALAR_SECTIONS (:61) is one line and inherits section-preservation structurally.

Pydantic model: new CreedConfig in src/charter/schemas.py, declared as creed: CreedConfig | None = None on CharterYaml (:263) — not nested under GovernanceConfig (:132). GovernanceConfig is the extracted/derived namespace whose two dead registers (:149, :164) are the decay precedent; a creed is a hand-authored operator declaration and belongs at the root beside catalog/directives. None default keeps _prune_optional_empties (:337) byte-stable per NFR-005.

Producer, shipped in the same commit as the schema (the 3-for-3 answer — Part 3 is the producer, and it must be code, not a plan):

Stage	Surface	file:line
Ask	QUESTION_ORDER / QUESTION_PROMPTS / CharterInterview	src/charter/interview.py:125, :150, :187
Default (non-interactive)	default_interview + packaged defaults	src/charter/interview.py:254, :566, src/charter/defaults.yaml
Persist answers	write_interview_answers	src/charter/interview.py:345
Write the block	write_compiled_charter → update_charter_yaml_section(path, "creed", …)	src/charter/compiler.py:405, :445-446 pattern
Read the block	load_creed_config(repo_root) mirroring load_governance_config	src/charter/sync.py:233 seam, validate at :252 pattern
Coverage gate, same commit	scan_creed_coverage(ctx) mirroring _check_unreconciled_tensions's fail-closed shape	src/charter/consistency_check.py:1017 as the template; wired into run_consistency_check :1050

The coverage gate is non-negotiable and is what distinguishes this from severity: it must report absent and partial creeds as findings, exactly as scan_unreconciled_tensions reports half-reconciled pairs (:1013). Note explicitly: do not copy sync.py:249-251's silent empty-config fallback.

---

Q3 — impacts: field on edges, not a Relation member — and in_tension_with survives

Recommendation: optional annotation field on DRGEdge. in_tension_with is NOT retired and does NOT become a band.

Cost of each option, priced:

Option	Cost	Verdict
New Relation.IMPACTS member	RELATION_DESCRIPTIONS totality (src/doctrine/drg/models.py:138; gate tests/doctrine/drg/test_models.py:58); a >40-char, distinct (:77) description; a verbatim-matching ### …\impacts`` section in docs/architecture/doctrine-relationships.md(tests/doctrine/test_relation_doc_parity.py:49,123); everyRelation-keyed table. ~4 files, bounded. But semantically wrong:impacts is a magnitude, not an edge role. An impacts edge with no relation type says two nodes interact without saying how — the exact vector-wash the verdict identified.	Reject
Numeric field on DRGEdge	src/doctrine/drg/models.py:328-339 already carries optional authored-only when and reason; impacts joins them additively. Real cost: the extractor's field-by-field writer (:299-303) must learn it or it silently won't round-trip; plus a validity domain (below).	Adopt

The load-bearing sub-answer. Making impacts numeric does not make in_tension_with one band of a continuum, and it must not be allowed to:

• in_tension_with is a typed existence claim with a lifecycle: symmetric, stored as a single canonical lexicographic edge, and consumed as set membership by _tension_candidate_pairs (src/charter/consistency_check.py:947,949) and both-sides bridging by _tension_reconciled_urns (:972). A band makes pair membership a function of a tunable threshold — and the verdict measured that no threshold separates genuine tensions (opposition 4–6) from unrelated pairs (2–4), overlapping at 4, with 5/5 false positives across 47,900 candidate pairs.
• Therefore: impacts is a strength annotation on an already-authored, already-typed edge, and is never a membership criterion. {relation: in_tension_with, impacts: "-0.7"} reads "this authored tension is severe." scan_unreconciled_tensions (:977) is untouched; ADR 2026-07-21-1's single-relation decision is untouched; the 2 authored tension edges (src/doctrine/directive.graph.yaml:90-93, :103-106) keep working.

What it costs, honestly. impacts on requires is semantically murky (requires already implies positive coupling), so the field needs a documented validity domain — and the moment that domain is a dict[Relation, ...] or frozenset[Relation], there is no totality guard (tests/doctrine/drg/test_kind_mapping_totality.py:49-52 covers ArtifactKind/NodeKind only). Price: a Relation arm on that scanner in the same commit. Cheaper alternative I'd take first: no per-relation table at all — allow impacts on any relation, document it as "meaningful on in_tension_with / rejects / refines; ignored elsewhere," and let the reader decide. A .get-shaped consumer needs no table, and no table means nothing to rot.

---

Q4 — Per-artefact field: exact kinds and shape

Exact kind list — 6 kinds, declared as a positive frozenset, not a negative exclusion:

directive, tactic, styleguide, toolguide, paradigm, procedure

Derivation: the 9 charter-activatable ArtifactKind members (src/doctrine/artifact_kinds.py:210-214, i.e. all 12 minus _NON_AUGMENTATION_ELIGIBLE_KINDS = {template, asset, anti_pattern} at :201), minus three that are not prescriptive practice statements:

Excluded	Why
template, asset	Design says exempt. Structurally confirmed: template has no Pydantic model (only dataclasses at src/doctrine/template_catalog.py:70,95) and an empty glob (src/doctrine/artifact_kinds.py:74); asset has no repository. There is nowhere to put the field.
anti_pattern	No model, no artefact file (src/doctrine/artifact_kinds.py:77-84) — it is a re-kinded node inside a graph fragment. A value vector on a negation is ambiguous by construction.
glossary_pack	Terminology, not behaviour. No trade to score.
agent_profile	An actor, not a practice. A profile value vector is the §6 squad-composition mechanism the verdict killed for having zero prior art (manifesto-tier-verdict-and-handover.md:169). Also the only model that ignores extras (src/doctrine/agent_profiles/profile.py:254), so a stray field there fails silently rather than loudly.
mission_step_contract	Workflow I/O contract, structural not behavioural.

Positive, not negative, and this matters: _NON_AUGMENTATION_ELIGIBLE_KINDS is an exclusion set — a new kind is silently included by default. For value-bearing that default is wrong: a new kind would silently acquire a scoring obligation nobody authored. A positive _VALUE_BEARING_KINDS frozenset means a new kind defaults to not value-bearing, and gets one only when someone writes it down. Pin it with an exactness test mirroring tests/doctrine/test_artifact_kinds.py:151.

Field shape. Name values, a list (not a mapping), of {name, delta, rationale} — field names verbatim from the corpus (creed-and-values-design-as-proposed.md:100-107) so the 36-vector calibration set imports with zero transformation. A list also preserves authored order; duplicate name is caught by a mode="after" validator (a mapping would give that free, but would break corpus round-trip — the round-trip is worth more).

delta: string on the wire, Decimal in memory. This is neither of the two options in the prompt, and it is the right one:

	String	Float	String→Decimal
Round-trips corpus byte-identically	✅	❌ "0.9" → 0.9 reformats	✅
Arithmetic for base + 0.5×fo/6	❌	✅	✅ exact
Comparison needs tolerance	n/a	✅ needs epsilon	❌ exact
Preserves authored precision (0.125, 0.05 grid, creed-…:172)	✅	⚠️ representation drift	✅
Range/granularity enforceable in schema	⚠️ regex only	✅	✅ both

Pick string→Decimal. condecimal(ge=-1, le=1, max_digits=4, decimal_places=3) plus a mode="before" validator that rejects a non-str raw input — because Decimal(float) is lossy, so an unquoted delta: 0.9 in YAML (which ruamel yields as float) must be a hard error, not a silent conversion. That closes the precision-drift defect class by construction rather than by authoring discipline (DIRECTIVE_043).

On the mandatory-negative rule (§5.6): measured, a hard minItems: 1 on negatives rejects 39% of the operator's own corpus. Ship it as a consistency-check finding, not a validator — same tier as scan_unreconciled_tensions, in src/charter/consistency_check.py. That keeps the review heuristic (which the verdict says is the one contribution that survived all four lenses, manifesto-tier-verdict-and-handover.md:135-141) without making the calibration set unloadable. The operator's decision then becomes reversible in one line instead of a schema migration.

---

Q5 — ValueConnascence N×N: home, reader, and the composition invariant

Home: inside the ValueSet artefact (src/doctrine/values/built-in/ammerse.valueset.yaml), not on the charter. It is library knowledge, org-replaceable, and it must travel with the basis it indexes — a matrix and a value list that can drift apart is the ammerse-analysis-template.md:69 Environmental drift repeated at N² scale. Co-location makes basis/matrix consistency a single-artefact validator (matrix keys == values keys, both dimensions) instead of a cross-file freshness check.

Representation: a nested mapping dict[ValueKey, dict[ValueKey, Decimal]] with an mode="after" validator asserting squareness, key-set equality with values, and zero diagonal. Not a flat list of triples (unreadable at 49 entries), not a positional matrix (breaks the moment a consumer reorders).

Reader: exactly one — a pure function project_values(deltas, value_set) -> tuple[ValueProjection, ...]. No other module reads the matrix. That is how this avoids becoming the routing-catalog failure: the routing catalog rotted because routing_policy/task_fit had a schema and a scoring evaluator but a producer that covered 1 of 21 verbs. Here the producer (36 authored vectors) exists before the reader, and the reader is one function with one signature.

The composition invariant — and it is already authored doctrine, not a new invention:

src/doctrine/tactics/built-in/analysis/ammerse-impact-analysis.tactic.yaml:61-62 and :68:

first_order path:  base + (0.5 × first_order_sum / 6)
high-stakes path:  overall = base + (0.5 × first_order) + (0.25 × second_order)

So: authored delta == base. It is the only persisted term. first_order and overall are derived. Any schema field able to hold them contradicts an activated, procedure-mandated tactic (src/doctrine/procedure.graph.yaml:297-299).

The storage rule that prevents computed values being written back as authored ones — four structural locks, not one convention:

1. The persisted model cannot hold a computed value. ValueDelta has exactly {name, delta, rationale}, extra="forbid", frozen=True (mirroring src/doctrine/tactics/models.py:74). There is no field to write into and no setter to write with.
2. The computed value is a different type in a different module, with no serializer. ValueProjection is a frozen dataclass in doctrine.values.projection, carrying base, first_order, overall, matrix_id, matrix_version. It is not a Pydantic model — so it has no model_dump(), and therefore no path into any YAML writer, which is the actual mechanism (every doctrine writer in this repo serializes via model_dump(); see src/doctrine/base.py:210, src/charter/schemas.py:377).
3. Provenance is mandatory on the projection. matrix_id + matrix_version are required fields with no defaults, so a projection can never be mistaken for an authored base — a value without a matrix stamp is an authored base, by type.
4. A pin test on the persisted shape: set(ValueDelta.model_fields) == {"name", "delta", "rationale"} exactly. That is a legitimate closed pin (unlike the value set, which must stay open) and it goes red the day someone adds computed_overall.

Lock 2 is the load-bearing one. Locks 1, 3, 4 are cheap reinforcement.

---

Q6 — What breaks, and do FoundationalValues become DRG nodes?

No — nothing in this design becomes a DRG node, and the three silent-drop sites do not bite it. That is the design's single best structural property.

Design element	DRG surface	Silent-drop exposure
ValueSet + matrix	BaseDoctrineRepository only; no ArtifactKind, no NodeKind, no URN, never in a *.graph.yaml	None. Never reaches query.py:230-242 bucketing, context.py:668-683's missing else, or extractor.py:133-145's _KIND_MAP
creed: block	charter.yaml section	None — not a node
Per-artefact values:	field on an existing node's artefact YAML	None — the node already exists; the field never becomes an edge
DRGEdge.impacts	field on an existing edge	Not _KIND_MAP — but does hit the extractor's field-by-field writer (models.py:299-303), a fourth silent-drop site not in the verdict's list of three

Consequence to state plainly: the silent-drop closure is not a prerequisite for this design. That is the difference between it and the rejected manifesto NodeKind (41–59 files, manifesto-tier-verdict-and-handover.md:168). But it is spent the instant anyone proposes making the value set a first-class kind so it can be charter activated — at which point the full cost returns: artifact_kinds.py _PLURALS/_PATTERNS, the 12-member literal pin (tests/doctrine/test_artifact_kinds.py:32), the NodeKind superset (tests/doctrine/drg/test_nodekind_artifactkind.py:18), the AST totality scanner, and all three drop sites. Forswear activation of the value set explicitly, in the ADR.

---

CONCRETE SHAPES

1. Value set + connascence matrix — src/doctrine/values/built-in/ammerse.valueset.yaml

schema_version: "1.0"
id: ammerse
name: AMMERSE Value System
attribution: >
  The AMMERSE value system is the work of J.B. Crossland (https://www.ammerse.org).
  "AMMERSE", "AMMERSE Method", "AMMERSE Theory", and "AMMERSE Value System" are
  trademarks of J.B. Crossland. Used with the author's authorization. This artefact
  is an accreditation, not a license of the consultancy framework.

# Ordered. Order is presentation only -- the matrix is keyed, never positional.
values:
  - key: agile
    name: Agile
    description: >
      The ability to adapt quickly to changes, incorporate feedback, and maintain
      flexibility in processes and decision-making.
  - key: minimal
    name: Minimal
    description: >
      The focus on simplicity and avoiding unnecessary complexity in processes
      and systems.
  - key: maintainable
    name: Maintainable
    description: >
      The ease of keeping processes and systems in working condition over time.
  - key: environmental
    name: Environmental
    description: >
      Considering the broader context, including cultural fit, impact on nature
      and society, standards, and ethical considerations.
  - key: reachable
    name: Reachable
    description: >
      Setting practical goals and ensuring they are achievable within the given
      constraints.
  - key: solvable
    name: Solvable
    description: >
      The ability to effectively solve problems and address challenges that arise.
  - key: extensible
    name: Extensible
    description: >
      The capacity to extend or scale processes and systems to meet future needs.

# ValueConnascence. matrix[a][b] = "how a change in `a` propagates to `b`",
# on the same [-1;1] sabotages<->reinforces scale. Square, zero diagonal,
# keys == `values[].key` exactly (validated). Illustrative values below --
# the authored first-order matrix is imported from the licensed source under
# the attribution above; do NOT hand-invent cells.
connascence:
  matrix_version: "1.0"
  first_order:
    agile:         {agile: "0", minimal: "0.3",  maintainable: "-0.1", environmental: "0",    reachable: "0.2",  solvable: "0.1",  extensible: "0.1"}
    minimal:       {agile: "0.3",  minimal: "0", maintainable: "0.4",  environmental: "0.1",  reachable: "0.5",  solvable: "-0.1", extensible: "-0.3"}
    maintainable:  {agile: "-0.1", minimal: "0.4",  maintainable: "0", environmental: "0.2",  reachable: "-0.2", solvable: "0.2",  extensible: "0.4"}
    environmental: {agile: "0",    minimal: "0.1",  maintainable: "0.2", environmental: "0",  reachable: "0.1",  solvable: "0.1",  extensible: "0.1"}
    reachable:     {agile: "0.2",  minimal: "0.5",  maintainable: "-0.2", environmental: "0.1", reachable: "0",   solvable: "0.3",  extensible: "-0.2"}
    solvable:      {agile: "0.1",  minimal: "-0.1", maintainable: "0.2", environmental: "0.1", reachable: "0.3",  solvable: "0",    extensible: "0.2"}
    extensible:    {agile: "0.1",  minimal: "-0.3", maintainable: "0.4", environmental: "0.1", reachable: "-0.2", solvable: "0.2",  extensible: "0"}
  # second_order is OPTIONAL. Absent => the high-stakes path at
  # ammerse-impact-analysis.tactic.yaml:68 is unavailable and project_values()
  # raises rather than substituting zeros.
  second_order: null

2. Creed — charter.yaml block (weights only; no value definitions, no matrix)

# .kittify/charter/charter.yaml  (top-level key, sibling of `governance:` / `catalog:`)
creed:
  value_set: ammerse          # resolves through ValueSetRepository (built-in|org|project)
  value_set_version: "1.0"
  # One entry per value in the resolved set. `weight` is importance-to-us on
  # [0;1] (NOT a delta -- a delta is a change, a weight is a standing priority).
  # `rationale` is mandatory and is the load-bearing field: it is what an LLM
  # reads. A weight without a rationale is unfalsifiable.
  weights:
    - name: minimal
      weight: "0.9"
      rationale: >
        Single canonical authority is the project's first principle; we would
        rather delete a surface than add a second one. We accept slower delivery
        of new capability to keep the surface count down.
    - name: maintainable
      weight: "0.85"
      rationale: >
        The corpus is dogfooded by agents with cold context; anything that needs
        a discipline reminder to stay correct is treated as structurally broken.
    - name: solvable
      weight: "0.7"
      rationale: >
        We prefer closing a defect class by construction over resolving the
        instance, and will pay a larger diff for it.
    - name: agile
      weight: "0.5"
      rationale: >
        Deliberately mid-ranked. We hold planning gates ahead of velocity and
        will refuse to ship a schema without its producer.
    - name: reachable
      weight: "0.4"
      rationale: >
        Explicitly de-prioritised: three scoring registers shipped as reachable
        slots and went inert. We now treat "ship the schema, populate later" as
        a defect, and give up short-term progress signals to do so.
    - name: extensible
      weight: "0.4"
      rationale: >
        Extension points are earned by a second real consumer, not anticipated.
    - name: environmental
      weight: "0.35"
      rationale: >
        Considered, but this is developer tooling; ecological and societal reach
        is indirect. We do not claim more than that.

3. Python — the four types + the two seams

# src/doctrine/values/models.py
from __future__ import annotations
from decimal import Decimal
from typing import Annotated, Any, Self
from pydantic import BaseModel, ConfigDict, Field, condecimal, model_validator

#: A value key. Deliberately NOT an enum: the value set is consumer-replaceable
#: (built-in -> org -> project via ValueSetRepository). A closed StrEnum here
#: would mean "fork the CLI to add a value".
ValueKey = Annotated[str, Field(pattern=r"^[a-z][a-z0-9_]*$")]

#: [-1;1] at 0.05-grid resolution (22 distinct |values| measured in the
#: calibration corpus, one 0.125 outlier). Decimal, never float: exact
#: comparison, no tolerance, no representation drift.
Normalized = Annotated[Decimal, condecimal(ge=Decimal("-1"), le=Decimal("1"),
                                           max_digits=4, decimal_places=3)]


def _require_authored_as_string(raw: Any, field: str) -> Any:
    """Reject an unquoted YAML number for a normalized field.

    ruamel yields `float` for an unquoted `delta: 0.9`, and Decimal(float) is
    lossy -- so the authored precision the corpus depends on would silently
    drift. Rejecting non-str at the boundary closes that class by construction
    rather than by authoring discipline.
    """
    if isinstance(raw, dict) and field in raw and not isinstance(raw[field], str):
        raise ValueError(
            f"{field!r} must be authored as a quoted string (e.g. {field}: \"-0.25\"), "
            f"got {type(raw[field]).__name__}. Unquoted YAML numbers lose authored "
            f"precision."
        )
    return raw


class FoundationalValue(BaseModel):
    """One value in a replaceable value set. Not an enum member."""
    model_config = ConfigDict(frozen=True, extra="forbid")
    key: ValueKey
    name: str
    description: str = Field(min_length=40)   # a slogan is not a definition


class ValueConnascence(BaseModel):
    """The N x N ripple matrix. matrix[a][b] = propagation of a into b."""
    model_config = ConfigDict(frozen=True, extra="forbid")
    matrix_version: str
    first_order: dict[ValueKey, dict[ValueKey, Normalized]]
    second_order: dict[ValueKey, dict[ValueKey, Normalized]] | None = None


class ValueSet(BaseModel):
    """The runtime authority for which values exist and how they interact.

    Substitutable wholesale by an org/project layer (doctrine.base._merge is a
    whole-field replace) -- which is the correct grain: a 7-value list paired
    with a 5x5 matrix is incoherent, so the pair moves atomically.
    """
    model_config = ConfigDict(frozen=True, extra="forbid", populate_by_name=True)
    id: str = Field(pattern=r"^[a-z][a-z0-9-]*$")
    schema_version: str = Field(pattern=r"^1\.0$")
    name: str
    attribution: str | None = None
    values: list[FoundationalValue] = Field(min_length=1)
    connascence: ValueConnascence

    @property
    def keys(self) -> frozenset[str]:
        return frozenset(v.key for v in self.values)

    @model_validator(mode="after")
    def _matrix_is_square_over_declared_keys(self) -> Self:
        declared = self.keys
        if len(declared) != len(self.values):
            raise ValueError("duplicate value key in `values`")
        for label, matrix in (("first_order", self.connascence.first_order),
                              ("second_order", self.connascence.second_order)):
            if matrix is None:
                continue
            if set(matrix) != declared:
                raise ValueError(
                    f"connascence.{label} rows {sorted(set(matrix))} != "
                    f"declared values {sorted(declared)}"
                )
            for row, cols in matrix.items():
                if set(cols) != declared:
                    raise ValueError(f"connascence.{label}[{row}] is not square")
                if cols[row] != 0:
                    raise ValueError(f"connascence.{label}[{row}][{row}] must be 0")
        return self


class ValueDelta(BaseModel):
    """One authored axis of a per-artefact value vector.

    THE PERSISTED SHAPE, AND THE ONLY ONE. `delta` is the *base* term of
    ammerse-impact-analysis.tactic.yaml:61-62 -- the change caused by adopting
    this artefact, relative to not adopting it. First- and second-order ripple
    are DERIVED (see ValueProjection) and have no field here to be written into:
    `extra="forbid"` + `frozen=True` make write-back structurally impossible,
    not merely discouraged.
    """
    model_config = ConfigDict(frozen=True, extra="forbid")
    name: ValueKey
    delta: Normalized
    rationale: str = Field(min_length=1)

    @model_validator(mode="before")
    @classmethod
    def _reject_unquoted_delta(cls, data: Any) -> Any:
        return _require_authored_as_string(data, "delta")

# src/doctrine/values/projection.py  -- deliberately NOT Pydantic.
from dataclasses import dataclass
from decimal import Decimal

_FIRST_ORDER_COEFF = Decimal("0.5")
_SECOND_ORDER_COEFF = Decimal("0.25")


@dataclass(frozen=True)
class ValueProjection:
    """A COMPUTED value figure. Never persisted, and structurally unpersistable.

    This is a plain frozen dataclass, not a BaseModel, specifically so it has no
    `model_dump()`. Every doctrine/charter writer in this repo serializes via
    `model_dump()` (doctrine/base.py:210, charter/schemas.py:377), so there is
    no code path that can write a projection into an artefact or a charter.
    That is the composition invariant's enforcement -- not a comment.

    `matrix_id`/`matrix_version` are required with no defaults: a figure without
    a matrix stamp IS an authored base, by type.
    """
    name: str
    base: Decimal
    first_order: Decimal
    overall: Decimal
    matrix_id: str
    matrix_version: str


def project_values(
    deltas: tuple["ValueDelta", ...],
    value_set: "ValueSet",
    *,
    high_stakes: bool = False,
) -> tuple[ValueProjection, ...]:
    """The ONE reader of the connascence matrix.

    Implements ammerse-impact-analysis.tactic.yaml:61-62 (standard path) and
    :68 (high-stakes path). Raises when `high_stakes=True` and the active set
    carries no second_order matrix -- it never substitutes zeros, because a
    zero ripple and an unknown ripple are different claims.
    """
    ...

4. Per-artefact field — YAML + model (×6 kinds)

# any of: *.directive.yaml | *.tactic.yaml | *.styleguide.yaml
#         | *.toolguide.yaml | *.paradigm.yaml | *.procedure.yaml
# Optional. Absent means "not assessed" -- NOT "neutral on every axis".
values:
  - {name: agile,         delta: "0.9",   rationale: "Strong focus on rapid adaptation and iterative learning."}
  - {name: minimal,       delta: "-0.25", rationale: "Adds documentation and experiment tracking; net negative but low."}
  - {name: maintainable,  delta: "-0.15", rationale: "Minor drag: one more artefact to keep current."}
  - {name: environmental, delta: "0.45",  rationale: "Surfaces blast radius before commitment."}
  - {name: reachable,     delta: "0.45",  rationale: "Bounds the change to something completable in one pass."}
  - {name: solvable,      delta: "0.6",   rationale: "Names the failure mode, so the fix is targetable."}
  - {name: extensible,    delta: "0.15",  rationale: "Neutral-to-slight: no extension points added or removed."}

# added to EACH of the 6 models -- e.g. src/doctrine/tactics/models.py:84,
# after `notes`. Field name `values` is safe: Pydantic v2 reserves only the
# `model_` prefix.
    values: list[ValueDelta] = Field(default_factory=list)
    """Authored value-impact vector (optional).

    Empty list means NOT ASSESSED -- it is never read as "neutral on every
    axis". Keys are validated against the ACTIVE ValueSet at resolve time, not
    against a module-level literal, so a consumer-replaced value set works
    without a code change.

    NOTE on layering: doctrine.base._merge (base.py:308-311) is a whole-field
    replace. An org/project override of this artefact replaces the ENTIRE
    vector; per-axis tuning is not supported, deliberately -- a partially
    re-authored vector mixes two assessors' mental models.
    """

    @model_validator(mode="after")
    def _value_names_are_unique(self) -> Self:
        names = [v.name for v in self.values]
        if len(set(names)) != len(names):
            raise ValueError("duplicate value name in `values`")
        return self

# src/doctrine/schemas/tactic.schema.yaml -- MUST land in the same commit,
# because additionalProperties:false at :6 is gated by
# tests/doctrine/test_artifact_compliance.py:21 / test_tactic_compliance.py:68.
# Add under `definitions:` (:12):
  value_delta:
    type: object
    additionalProperties: false
    required: [name, delta, rationale]
    properties:
      name:
        type: string
        pattern: ^[a-z][a-z0-9_]*$
      delta:
        type: string          # STRING, not number -- preserves authored precision
        pattern: ^-?(0(\.\d{1,3})?|1(\.0{1,3})?)$
        description: Change caused by adopting this artefact, on [-1;1]. Quoted.
      rationale:
        type: string
        minLength: 1
# ... and under top-level `properties:` (:64):
  values:
    type: array
    minItems: 1
    items:
      $ref: '#/definitions/value_delta'
    description: >
      Authored value-impact vector. Absent means not assessed. Keys are checked
      against the active value set at resolve time, not by this schema.

5. Edge field — src/doctrine/drg/models.py:328-339

class DRGEdge(BaseModel):
    """A typed, directed relationship between two nodes."""

    source: str
    target: str
    relation: Relation
    when: str | None = None
    reason: str | None = None
    #: Bounded interaction strength on the sabotages <-> reinforces scale,
    #: [-1;1], authored as a quoted string. An ANNOTATION on an
    #: already-typed edge -- never a membership criterion.
    #:
    #: It does NOT make `in_tension_with` one band of a continuum:
    #: consistency_check._tension_candidate_pairs (:947-951) selects pairs by
    #: exact relation equality and set membership. Deriving pair membership
    #: from a numeric threshold was measured at 5/5 false positives over
    #: ~47.9k candidate pairs (opposition counts overlap: genuine 4-6,
    #: unrelated 2-4). ADR 2026-07-21-1's single-relation decision stands.
    #:
    #: Meaningful on `in_tension_with` / `rejects` / `refines`; carried but
    #: unread elsewhere. Deliberately NO dict[Relation, ...] validity table:
    #: test_kind_mapping_totality._ENUM_CLASSES (:49-52) covers only
    #: ArtifactKind/NodeKind, so a Relation-keyed table would ship with no
    #: totality guard and rot on the next Relation member.
    impacts: Normalized | None = None
    provenance: str | None = None

# src/doctrine/directive.graph.yaml:90-93 -- the existing authored tension,
# annotated. The relation is unchanged; only strength is added.
- source: directive:DIRECTIVE_024
  target: directive:DIRECTIVE_025
  relation: in_tension_with
  impacts: "-0.7"
  reason: >
    Locality of Change vetoes growth of the file set that the Boy Scout Rule
    expands. See directive:RECONCILE_CHANGE_SCOPE_TENSIONS.

---

SEAM-CHANGE INVENTORY

Part 1 — Creed and Values

New files

• src/doctrine/values/__init__.py, models.py, projection.py, repository.py (ValueSetRepository(BaseDoctrineRepository[ValueSet]), _glob = "*.valueset.yaml")
• src/doctrine/values/built-in/ammerse.valueset.yaml
• src/doctrine/schemas/valueset.schema.yaml (parity with the 7 existing schemas; note it will be dead at load time like the others — src/doctrine/tactics/validation.py:17 has no callers — but live in tests/doctrine/test_artifact_compliance.py:21)
• tests/doctrine/values/ — model validators, matrix squareness, string-only delta, projection formulas vs ammerse-impact-analysis.tactic.yaml:61-62,:68, the persisted-shape pin, the openness guard (no hardcoded 7-key literal in src/)

Modified — per-artefact field (×6 kinds, 12 files)

• src/doctrine/directives/models.py:49 · src/doctrine/tactics/models.py:84 · src/doctrine/styleguides/models.py:79 · src/doctrine/toolguides/models.py:9 · src/doctrine/paradigms/models.py:67 · src/doctrine/procedures/models.py:103
• src/doctrine/schemas/{directive,tactic,styleguide,toolguide,paradigm,procedure}.schema.yaml (:6 additionalProperties: false; add definitions.value_delta + properties.values)
• src/doctrine/artifact_kinds.py — new positive _VALUE_BEARING_KINDS frozenset beside _NON_AUGMENTATION_ELIGIBLE_KINDS (:201)
• tests/doctrine/test_artifact_kinds.py — exactness pin mirroring :151

Deliberately NOT modified

• src/doctrine/service.py:65-150 — no new @property (see the BLOCKER); expose via a named accessor
• src/doctrine/artifact_kinds.py:92 ArtifactKind — no new member
• src/doctrine/drg/models.py:27 NodeKind — no new member
• any *.graph.yaml

Campsite, same mission

• delete src/charter/schemas.py:164 Directive.severity and :149 GovernanceConfig.enforcement
• DIRECTIVE_044 unification: src/doctrine/templates/architecture/ammerse-analysis-template.md:33,45,57,69,81,93,105 → point at the value set instead of restating; restore "impact on nature" at :69

Part 2 — impacts on edges

• src/doctrine/drg/models.py:328-339 — add impacts: Normalized | None = None
• src/doctrine/drg/migration/extractor.py — teach the field-by-field edge writer (the mechanism named at models.py:299-303) to emit impacts; without this the field silently does not round-trip
• src/doctrine/drg/validator.py — range already enforced by the annotation; add nothing
• src/doctrine/directive.graph.yaml:90-93, :103-106 — annotate the 2 authored tension edges (the only sensible first population)
• docs/architecture/doctrine-relationships.md — a note that impacts annotates, never types. No new ### section needed because no Relation member is added, so tests/doctrine/test_relation_doc_parity.py:49 stays green
• tests/doctrine/drg/test_models.py — impacts default None, range rejection, string-only, round-trip through model_dump
• Untouched, and verify so: src/charter/consistency_check.py:934-1014

Part 3 — Charter creation

• src/charter/schemas.py — new CreedWeight + CreedConfig; creed: CreedConfig | None = None on CharterYaml (:263); add creed keys to _OPTIONAL_EMPTY_OMIT_KEYS (:313) if any list can be empty
• src/charter/charter_yaml_io.py:61 — add "creed" to _SCALAR_SECTIONS
• src/charter/sync.py — new load_creed_config(repo_root) after :269, following the :233→:252 validate pattern but three-state, not silent-empty
• src/charter/compiler.py:405 write_compiled_charter — update_charter_yaml_section(path, "creed", …) beside :445-446; extend _bootstrap_charter_yaml (:540) and CharterYaml(...) (:573)
• src/charter/interview.py:125,150,187,254,566 + src/charter/defaults.yaml — the creed question set (the producer). LLM-chosen probes per §3, mapped through src/charter/synthesizer/interview_mapping.py
• src/specify_cli/cli/commands/charter/interview.py:237,303 and _widen.py:266 — prompt wiring
• src/charter/consistency_check.py — scan_creed_coverage(ctx) + _check_creed_coverage mirroring :1017's fail-closed shape; wire into run_consistency_check (:1050) and ConsistencyReport (:147)
• src/specify_cli/upgrade/migrations/m_*.py — seed an absent creed: in existing projects (pattern: m_unify_charter_activation_finalize.py:315)
• docs/architecture/06_unified_charter_bundle.md:31-49 — the tracked/hash table gains the creed section
• tests/charter/test_charter_yaml_model.py:73-201 — creed round-trip, absent-key three-state, extra="forbid" still rejects a stray nested key

---

WHAT BREAKS

#	Surface	Breaks how	Order
1	tests/doctrine/test_artifact_compliance.py:21, test_tactic_compliance.py:68	values: in a built-in YAML with additionalProperties: false still at schemas/*.yaml:6 → red	Model + schema + data in one commit
2	tests/architectural/test_artifact_selection_completeness.py:80,118,150	Red three ways the moment ValueSetRepository becomes a DoctrineService property	Don't. Use a named accessor
3	tests/charter/test_charter_yaml_model.py:86	CharterYaml.model_validate on a dump containing creed fails until the field is declared (schemas.py:286 extra="forbid")	Field before data
4	src/charter/charter_yaml_io.py:151	UnknownCharterYamlSectionError on the first creed write	_SCALAR_SECTIONS before the writer
5	src/charter/bundle.py:141 + src/specify_cli/charter_runtime/freshness/computer.py:295-331	creed: changes the bundle content hash → every existing project reads stale on upgrade	Migration in the same release
6	src/doctrine/drg/migration/extractor.py edge writer	DRGEdge.impacts silently absent from regenerated *.graph.yaml; graph-freshness tests then diff	Writer before any authored impacts
7	tests/architectural/test_no_legacy_terminology.py	Mission/canonical-term guard on new doctrine prose; CI-only job	Run locally pre-push (~0.1 s)
8	tests/_arch_shard_map.py:81-87,155,226 + tests/architectural/test_golden_count_ban.py:131,272	Every new test file must be appended to a shard tuple; every new len(x) == N needs # golden-count: cardinality-is-contract	With each new test file
9	src/charter/schemas.py:313-334 NFR-005	An emitted creed: null / creed: {} breaks byte-stability of default fixtures	CreedConfig \| None = None, prune on empty
10	36-vector import	Corpus authored against ammerse-analysis-template.md:69's drifted Environmental definition	DIRECTIVE_044 unification first

Explicitly not broken (and worth asserting in tests so it stays true): src/doctrine/drg/query.py:230-242, src/charter/context.py:668-683, src/doctrine/drg/migration/extractor.py:133-145, tests/doctrine/test_artifact_kinds.py:32, tests/doctrine/drg/test_kind_mapping_totality.py:183, tests/doctrine/drg/test_nodekind_artifactkind.py:18, tests/doctrine/drg/test_models.py:58, tests/doctrine/test_relation_doc_parity.py:49, src/charter/consistency_check.py:934-1014.

---

CONCESSION

• Nothing was executed. Every "breaks" claim is a static read of test source. No pytest run, no python -c. Item 5 (bundle-hash staleness) and item 6 (extractor round-trip) are the two most likely to be wrong in detail, because both depend on runtime behaviour I inferred from docstrings — models.py:299-303 describes an explicit field-by-field writer; I did not read that writer.
• _KIND_MAP/_classify_artifact_urns/query.py non-exposure is an argument, not a measurement. It follows from "no new ArtifactKind/NodeKind member," which is a design choice I am making, not a property I verified end-to-end. If any downstream consumer needs the value set to be charter activate-able, the whole exemption collapses and the full 41–59-file cost returns.
• The matrix cells in shape #1 are illustrative and I invented them. The verdict's correction 9 stands: the authored first-order matrix is not in this repository and both in-repo copies defer to an external URL. I marked them do NOT hand-invent, and then hand-invented placeholders to show the shape. Do not ship them.
• values as a field name: I assert Pydantic v2 reserves only the model_ prefix. I did not test a model with a values field. If it collides, value_deltas is the fallback and the corpus import gains a one-line rename.
• Out of my lens entirely: whether the 7 axes should be adopted (the §5.6 all-non-negative decision is explicitly the operator's), whether the #2538 gate should run first (planner-priti's call; the verdict says yes and I have no basis to disagree), and the trademark question. I designed the seam; I did not price the mission.
• I did not re-litigate the rejected design, per instruction — but one of its objections has a live residue I could not fully discharge: the verdict's §7.3 note that a per-artefact value field "collides with #2216's component-type all-artefact sweep." I did not read #2216. If that sweep is adding a different field to the same 6 models, the two must be sequenced, and this design's 12-file edit becomes a merge conflict with someone else's 12-file edit.

---

VERDICT

Structurally sound — materially more so than the rejected design, and for one specific reason: it needs no new ArtifactKind, no new NodeKind, no new Relation, and therefore does not touch a single one of this repo's fail-closed enum drift-guards or the three silent-drop sites. That is not a lucky accident of the proposal; it falls out of two facts the proposal half-saw — that BaseDoctrineRepository (src/doctrine/base.py:114-122) needs only _schema and _glob, and that a charter section is not a graph node. Once you take both, the "half-open enum" of Part 1 dissolves: there is no type to keep open, because the openness lives in a substitutable artefact and the validation target is the active value set rather than a module literal. Parts 2 and 3 are then genuinely cheap — impacts is a sibling of when/reason on DRGEdge, and creed: is a sibling of governance: on charter.yaml with the INV-9 chokepoint already built. The design's real exposure is not conceptual; it is the 12-file dual-gate (Pydantic extra="forbid" and additionalProperties: false, only one of which is load-enforced) and the DoctrineService-property tripwire, both of which are mechanical and both of which are now written down.

The one change that most improves it: stop treating delta as a persistence question and make the composition invariant the design's centre. It is already authored doctrine — ammerse-impact-analysis.tactic.yaml:61-62 and :68 define base + 0.5×first_order/6 and overall = base + 0.5×fo + 0.25×so — so delta is base, it is the only persistable term, and the way to guarantee that is not a rule but a type: make the computed figure a plain frozen dataclass with no model_dump(), in a module no writer imports, carrying a mandatory matrix_id/matrix_version stamp. Every doctrine and charter writer in this repository serializes through model_dump() (src/doctrine/base.py:210, src/charter/schemas.py:377); a projection that cannot produce one cannot be written back, ever, by anybody, including a future agent who does not read this document. Do that and the design's worst failure mode — a computed ripple silently laundered into an authored assessment and then re-composed against itself — is closed by construction rather than by a discipline reminder, which is exactly the bar DIRECTIVE_043 sets.agentId: af50fe3ba00bc15fd (use SendMessage with to: 'af50fe3ba00bc15fd', summary: '<5-10 word recap>' to continue this agent) subagent_tokens: 201287 tool_uses: 25 duration_ms: 946196