| Field | Value |
|---|
| Category | EXTERNAL Stakeholder |
| Actor Type | human |
| Primary Goal | Assess whether Spec Kitty architecture and decision model are robust enough for long-term organizational adoption. |
| Persona ID | aud-ext-architect-evaluator |
| Created / Updated | 2026-03-01 / 2026-11-13 |
| Domain / Context | Spec Kitty 4.x |
| Status | canonical |
Overview
- Role Focus: System boundaries, decision traceability, and architecture lifecycle sustainability.
- Primary Function: Evaluates whether Spec Kitty supports defensible architecture governance and evolution in real organizations.
- Environment / Context: Teams with multi-year codebase stewardship and high sensitivity to architecture drift.
Core Motivations
- Professional Drivers: Preserve coherent architecture direction and avoid undocumented, ad-hoc decision drift.
- Emotional or Cognitive Drivers: Prefers explicit rationale and model consistency over implicit convention.
- Systemic Positioning: Gatekeeper for architecture standards and governance fitness.
Desiderata
| Category | Expectation / Need | Description |
|---|
| Information | Strong architecture narrative | Needs consistent domain, context, container, and component descriptions with clear boundaries. |
| Interaction | Traceable decision flow | Expects architectural behavior to be linked to ADR rationale and supersession history (ADRs filed by era under docs/adr/; a decision changes through an appended, dated amendment or a superseding ADR, recorded in the older ADR’s status). |
| Support | Comparative evaluation material | Wants enough detail to compare Spec Kitty against existing architecture governance approaches. |
| Governance | Explicit authority boundaries | Requires clear separation between host authority and external integration adapters. |
| Decision Authority | Adoption sign-off influence | Can endorse or block architecture-level adoption decisions. |
Frustrations and Constraints
- Pain Points: Documentation that is aspirational but not anchored to tested behavior.
- Trade-Off Awareness: Accepts initial complexity if it prevents long-term governance entropy.
- Environmental Constraints: Legacy architecture commitments, audit requirements, and migration risk exposure.
Behavioral Cues
| Situation | Typical Behavior | Interpretation |
|---|
| Stable / Routine | Reviews structural coherence periodically | Maintains long-term architecture health through regular review. |
| Change / Uncertainty | Requests explicit alternatives and consequences | Protects against narrow, under-explained architectural choices. |
| Under Pressure | Enforces minimum architecture invariants | Prioritizes boundary integrity over short-term convenience. |
Collaboration Preferences
- Decision Style: Trade-off analysis with explicit consequences.
- Communication Style: Structured, rationale-heavy, and citation-backed.
- Feedback Expectations: Clear mismatch analysis between architecture docs and runtime/test behavior.
Design Impact
- Affected By: C4 layering quality, lifecycle FSM clarity, and runtime boundary modeling.
- Needs From Design: Architecture corpus that remains trustworthy during evolution.
- Risk If Ignored: Rejection due to low confidence in governance durability.
- Acceptance Signal: Architecture docs remain coherent under change and align with test-inferred behavior.
Measures of Success
| Dimension | Indicator | Type |
|---|
| Performance | Time to evaluate a major architecture proposal | Quantitative |
| Quality | Ratio of decisions with explicit alternatives and traceability | Quantitative |
| Growth | Confidence in maintaining architecture coherence over releases | Qualitative |
Narrative Summary
The External Architect Evaluator focuses on whether Spec Kitty can sustain
architectural integrity over time, not just bootstrap a project quickly. They
need clear boundaries, traceable decisions, and consistent behavior modeling
before recommending adoption.